Alice Kills Streaming Video Sharing Patent Claims

Case:  Videoshare LLC v. Google, Inc., No. 13-cv-990 (GMS) (D. Del. August 2, 2016).

Result: Rule 12(c) motion for judgment on the pleadings of invalidity under 35 U.S.C. § 101 was granted.

Patents: U.S. Patent No. 8,438,608 ("Sharing a streaming video"), and U.S. Patent No. 8,464,302 ("Method and system for sharing video with advertisements over a network").  The claims of the ’608 patent are directed to sharing streaming media over a network, including generating and embedding identification tags in a web page to share a streaming file.  The ’302 patent is directed to “sharing a streaming video and associated advertisement over a network.”  Representative claims of both patents can be seen at the foregoing links.

Abstract Idea (Alice Step 1): All claims of both patents were directed to “the abstract idea of preparing a video in streaming video format for sharing over a computer network.”  The court rejected the contention “that the claimed invention results in an improvement to computer functionality.”  Instead, “[a]t most, the claims merely automate a sequence of known steps using conventional technology so that a human is not burdened with various manual steps.”

Inventive Concept (Alice Step 2): None: “[t]he claims here specify only conventional steps at a high level of generality, and the association of an advertisement is not sufficient to provide an inventive concept.”

Takeaway: The claims here were directed to a technical environment, and recited steps in that environment.  This case is an illustration of a how a technical environment will not always save the claims.  To perhaps state the obvious, patent claims directed to internet advertising systems will continue to face a steep uphill climb when patent-eligibility is challenged under Section 101.

Upcoming Webinar

In the webinar, Bryan Hart will discuss the upcoming Supreme Court case Oil States Energy Services, LLC v. Greene’s Energy Group, LLC, which threatens to end the inter partes review procedure for examining and invalidating issued patents. Bryan wi…Register