Brittany Leigh

Image Display Patents Fail Alice Test: Gabara v. Facebook, Inc.

In granting a motion to dismiss for lack of patent-eligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C § 101, a court determined that patents relating to moving a portable unit to view an image of a stationary map and using a portable wireless system to improve the operations of a group communicating electronically are abstract ideas that do not include an inventive concept.  Gabara v. Facebook, Inc., No. 9cv9890(DLC) (S.D.N.Y. Sep. 4, 2020) Plaintiff Gabara alleged that Facebook committed direct, induced, and contributory infringement of the five patents at issue: US Patent Nos. 8,930,131; 8,620,545; 8,836,698; 8,706,400 (the “Image Patents”), and 9,299,348 (the “348 patent”).  The Image Patents The Image Patents are directed toward moving a portable unit, such as a mobile device, to view an image of a stationary map instead of scrolling on the device to change the view.  The court likened this concept to moving a telescope across a sky or a magnifying glass across a map. The court identified claim 1 of the ‘400 patent to be representative of the Image Patents.  Independent claim 1 is reproduced below: 1. A method of moving a portable unit to search for a new location comprising the steps of: displaying an… Read More »Image Display Patents Fail Alice Test: Gabara v. Facebook, Inc.